Bracket Maker

How to Run a Fair Blind Draw, and Why Some Shuffles Are Unfair

Without rankings, players accept a blind draw as long as every name has the same chance of every line. One shuffle shortcut found in a lot of web tools does not give that. Over a million runs in Chrome it left the first of four names in the first slot 32.8% of the time and in the last slot 12.5%, where both should be 25%.

Checked

Where the First Name on the List Ends Up

Four names, shuffled 20,000 times in your browser. A fair shuffle puts the first name in each slot 25% of the time

Sort Shortcut

Slot 1
Slot 2
Slot 3
Slot 4

Fisher–Yates

Slot 1
Slot 2
Slot 3
Slot 4
Fair share, 4 slots
25%
Shortcut, first slot
32.8%
Shortcut, last slot
12.5%
Runs
1,000,000

Why it matters: byes

With 6 teams or 12 the top seeds get a bye, one game fewer to win. If the shuffle favours the top of the list, the first people to sign up get the bye more often.

The shortcut is to sort the list with a comparison that answers at random. A sort is built to make as few comparisons as it can, which is too few to mix the list evenly.

How uneven depends on the browser and its version. In Chrome 156 the first of four names landed in the four slots 32.8%, 32.9%, 21.8%, 12.5% of the time. In Node.js 26 it was 28.1%, 28.2%, 25%, 18.7%, and with six names the first one took one of the two bye slots 43% of the time, where a fair draw gives 33.3%. The test at the top of this page runs in your own browser.

The shuffle button on every bracket here and the random team generator use the Fisher–Yates shuffle, which gives every order the same chance. In the same test it put the first name in each of four slots 25%, 25%, 24.9%, 25.1% of the time.

Three ways to draw without rankings

  1. 1Blind draw. Type the names in any order and shuffle once, in front of the room. Take the order as it falls.
  2. 2Split draw. Agree the two or four strongest teams and put them on the top lines so they cannot meet early. Shuffle the rest separately and add them below.
  3. 3Keeping clubmates apart. Shuffle, then look at round one. If two teams from the same club or the same car have drawn each other, swap one with the team on the next line.

Random Team Generator

Paste a list of players, deal them into teams or pairs, and send the teams straight into a bracket.

Open the team generator

Questions

More Guides

All 25 guides