Bracket Maker

Why Teams Meet Again Too Early in Double Elimination

You beat a team in the first round and lose in the second. They win their first game in the losers bracket, and there they are again. Whether that happens depends on one thing the bracket's designer chose: where the teams dropping from each winners round are placed.

Checked

WINNERS BRACKETLOSERS BRACKETQUARTERFINALSSEMIFINALSFINALGRAND FINALRESET, IF NEEDEDLOSERS ROUND 1LOSERS ROUND 2LOSERS ROUND 3LOSERS ROUND 41Hawks218Owls1514Bears185Sharks2121Hawks215Sharks1672Tigers217Rockets1233Wolves216Comets1942Tigers3Wolves81HawksWinner of game 812Winner of game 12Winner of game 1314Winner of game 14Loser of game 14158Owls214Bears175Loser of game 88Owls97Rockets146Comets2165Sharks6Comets10Winner of game 9Winner of game 1011Loser of game 12Winner of game 1113
Open a 32-team double elimination bracket
Brackets per test
200,000
16 teams, in order
2.75
16 teams, crossed
0.41
64 teams, crossed
0.37

What we counted

We played 200,000 brackets for each drop order at 8, 16, 32 and 64 teams, deciding every game by a coin flip, and counted every pairing that happened a second time.

Two games are left out: the last game of the losers bracket and the final. A rematch there cannot be designed away. Everything else is avoidable, and the table shows how many avoidable rematches each order produces per tournament.

TeamsDropped in orderReversed every other roundOrder used hereFirst round a rematch can happen here
81.000.250.25Losers round 3
162.750.410.41Losers round 4
326.190.790.40Losers round 5
6413.041.540.37Losers round 7
Avoidable Rematches per 64-Team Tournament

200,000 simulated brackets for each drop order

Dropped in order
13.04
Reversed every other round
1.54
Order used here
0.37

The usual rule works up to 16 teams

The rule most often given is to reverse the order of the dropping teams in every other round. At 8 and 16 teams nothing we tried does better.

At 32 teams it gives 0.79 avoidable rematches, twice as many as the best order, and most of them fall in losers round 4. At 64 teams that round averages one rematch in every tournament. The alternating pattern lines up two groups of teams that met in the winners bracket two rounds earlier.

There is no single formula that is best at every size. Each size needs its own order, found by trying the combinations.

TeamsDrop order, from the second winners round on
8Reversed, then in order
16Reversed, then in order twice
32Each half reversed, reversed, then in order twice
64Halves swapped, reversed, each half reversed, halves swapped, in order

On the printed sheet

None of this needs working out on the day. Every line in the losers bracket of a double elimination sheet here says where its team comes from, for example Loser of game 7, and the games are numbered in the order to play them.

Double Elimination Bracket

Free to fill in and print up to 32 teams. Each losers line is labelled with the game it comes from.

Open double elimination

Questions

More Guides

All 25 guides