Which Tournament Format Finds the Best Team?
Round robin is usually called the fairest format. In 200,000 simulated 8-team tournaments, seeded double elimination gave the title to the best team more often, 46.5% against 41.5%, in half the games. Round robin only came out ahead in a larger, closely matched field.
Checked
- Single, random draw
- 35.9%
- Single, seeded
- 40.5%
- Round robin
- 41.5%
- Double, seeded
- 46.5%
The test
Eight teams, each 50 Elo points stronger than the next. That means seed 1 beats seed 2 57.1% of the time and seed 8 88.2% of the time. We played 200,000 tournaments in each format on the brackets this site generates and counted how often seed 1 won.
The round robin winner is the team with the most wins, with ties going to the best record among the tied teams and then to a coin toss. Double elimination was played with the replay of the final.
200,000 tournaments per format, 50 Elo points between neighbouring seeds
Why double elimination beats a round robin here
In a round robin the best team has to finish alone on top of seven results, while the second-best team plays almost the same schedule with almost the same chances. In 34.1% of the simulated round robins two or more teams finished level on wins at the top.
Double elimination does something a table cannot: it makes the last two teams play each other, and it makes the challenger win twice.
Where round robin wins
Changing the size of the field and the gap between teams changes the answer.
| Field | Single, seeded | Double, seeded | Round robin |
|---|---|---|---|
| 8 teams, 25 Elo apart | 27% | 30.4% | 28.4% |
| 8 teams, 50 apart | 40.5% | 46.5% | 41.5% |
| 8 teams, 100 apart | 58.8% | 67% | 56.8% |
| 16 teams, 25 apart | 26.6% | 30.6% | 32.4% |
| 16 teams, 50 apart | 40.8% | 46.3% | 44.4% |
Reading the table
Round robin leads in one row: sixteen teams close together. When teams are nearly equal, only more games separate them, and a 16-team round robin has 120 games against 30 for the bracket.
With a wide gap the round robin was the worst of the three, behind even the 7-game knockout. A strong favourite in a knockout has to win three games. In a round robin it has to stay ahead of a second seed that is also beating nearly everyone. The 16-team rows are from 100,000 tournaments each.
What seeding is worth
Same format, same seven games: seeding moved the best team's chance from 35.9% to 40.5%. A seeded bracket produced a final between seeds 1 and 2 in 32.5% of tournaments; a random draw managed 16.3%.
The reason is simple. In a random draw the two best teams land in opposite halves 4/7 of the time with 8 teams (57.1%) and 8/15 with 16 (53.3%). The rest of the time one of them is gone before the final. Seeding costs no extra games.
Try the Formats on Your Own List
Type the teams once, then switch between single elimination, double elimination, Swiss and round robin.